Stability & Peace of Mind

in Life’s Ever Changing Landscape

10670 Route 322

Shippenville, PA 16254

Ph: (814) 226-9009

Fax: (814) 226-9064

Toll Free: (800) 617-8353


1109 N. Main Street Ext.

Butler, PA 16001

Ph: (724) 209-1575

Fax: (814) 240-5762

Toll Free: (800) 617-8353

Monday – Friday: 8:30-5:00
Saturday – Sunday: Closed

1109 N. Main Street Ext.
Butler, PA 16001
Ph: (724) 209-1575
Fax: (814) 240-5762

Monday – Friday: 9:00-5:00
Saturday: 9:00-1:00
Sunday: Closed

10670 US Route 322
Shippenville, PA 16254
Ph: (814) 226-6412
Fax: (814) 226-6358

Monday – Wednesday: 8:00-5:00
Thursday – Friday: 8:00-7:00
Saturday: 9:00-2:00
Sunday: Closed

All parties must be present at least one hour before closing for all title and notary work.

Insurance Solutions & Title Work Services

Auto & Leisure

Home & Property



Life & More

Title & Notary

Providing the best coverage & price the market has to offer.

Dedicated to Providing Superior Service

William P. Siegel


Our agents consider themselves “professional risk managers”, determined to provide each client with perfectly tailored coverage for their individual, family, business, and health insurance needs.

Jamie Baker-BillsPersonal Lines

Melissa Craig Accounting Specialist

Laura DallasPersonal Lines – Butler Office

Lindsey FoxPersonal Lines

Matt JohnsonPersonal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life

Linda LutzPersonal & Commercial Lines

Deanna MillerPersonal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life

Cindy NeelyPersonal Lines

Sheila RathfonCommercial Lines

Amber SchreckengostPersonal Lines

Jessica ShafferPersonal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life

Deb Shay Commercial Lines

Mary Lisa SiegelAdvertising & Marketing

Shari Smith-DividoReception

Tricia StewartPersonal Lines

Ryan WisniewskiPersonal & Commercial Lines – Butler office

Susie BearyTitle & Notary Specialist

Linda Clinger Title & Notary Specialist

Marie FletcherTitle & Notary Specialist

Deb SlaugenhauptBusiness Manager

Jim SmathersHealth & Life

We operate with an uncompromising belief in professionalism and integrity while striving to find innovative and effective ways to manage the needs of our clients.

Representing a Selection of A+ Rated Insurance Companies

Traditional Values. Contemporary Solutions. Contact Us.

For questions and inquiries regarding an existing insurance policy or to request a quote, please tell us about yourself and how we can help you. One of our insurance specialist will assist you shortly.

Fields marked with an * are required
Auto & Leisure

Personal Insurance Solutions

Not all Polices are the Same

Personal insurance is often thought of like a commodity. At Siegel Insurance we want to change that perception. Since there are so many variables that comprise a personal auto or home policy, people tend to not fully understand what they are paying for or if they are covered properly.

The agents at Siegel Insurance want to make sure that you not only understand the coverage you carry on your policy, but we want to make certain you carry the appropriate coverage for your individual needs. Although proper coverage is the main concern for us as insurance agents, we fully understand that price is typically the main concern for our clients. That is why we represent a broad selection of respected insurance companies that give us the ability to shop the market and find you the best value available.

Auto / Vehicle Policies

There are many considerations when selecting the proper way to cover you and your family on an auto insurance policy. At Siegel Insurance, we will deliver all options in straightforward terms. We want to provide you with knowledge, protection, and savings.

Home Policies

For most people their home is their biggest investment, so it is important to protect it and your belongings with proper insurance. At Siegel Insurance, we will review your existing policy and look for deficiencies and gaps in coverage. One of our licensed agents will provide a detailed explanation of all of your home insurance options.

Are you a renter or live in a condo or mobile home? Siegel Insurance has special policies designed for your situation as well.

Commercial / Business Solutions

Keeping the business protected

Running a successful business requires time, hard work, and dedication. Keeping the business protected against unforeseen events requires insurance. At Siegel Insurance, we have the expertise to analyze the risks involved with operating your business and develop an insurance package that fits your particular needs, so that when the unexpected happens, you and your business are fully protected. We use several of the insurance industry’s highest rated and most respected companies, combining the best available coverage with extremely competitive pricing.

Businesses we specialize in include:

Health Insurance Solutions

Anyone who has ever shopped for health insurance finds out pretty quickly that it can be perplexing and overwhelming. There are a lot of companies, a lot of options, and frankly, a lot of questions that need to be answered.

At Siegel Insurance, we have the expertise to help you navigate the confusing health insurance marketplace. Whether you are an individual or a business owner looking for a group policy, we can explain all of your options in a way that you will understand. We have access to all of the major health insurance companies in Pennsylvania including Highmark, UPMC, Health America, and United Health Care. Our clients can always feel confident they are getting the best value available for their individual or group health insurance needs.

Siegel Insurance also offers disability and long term care insurance products through the following companies:

The Standard


Principal Financial

Genworth Financial

John Hancock

Life Insurance

Purchasing life insurance can be a very confusing undertaking. We cut through the confusion to custom tailor a plan just right for you and your family. Whether you are looking for permanent or temporary life insurance policy.

What type of policy do I need? What company should I purchase from? How much coverage do I need?

At Siegel Insurance, not only will we help answer your questions but we will customize a plan that best fits your family situation. Whether you are looking for permanent or temporary life insurance policy, we have access to most of the major A-rated companies in the life insurance industry and will find you the most cost effective plan available.

Life Insurance Companies we work with include:

Met Life

West Coast Life

Mutual Of Omaha


Banner Life

Erie Family Life

Genworth Financial

Title & Notary

CLARION : Smathers Title & Notary

Smathers Title & Notary, Inc. also provides service through our expanded Pennsylvania Title Work operations. As an authorized PennDOT Messenger Service Agent, we provide immediate online servicing for PennDOT driver license and registration renewals. We can also replace your license plate or vehicle registration materials.(State and service fees apply.) We can process title transfers for cars, trucks, motorcycles, trailers, mobile homes, and motor homes quickly and efficiently. If your transactions can’t be processed online, we will deliver them to Harrisburg with our messenger service. We are members of the Pennsylvania On-Line Messenger Association.

We can issue fishing licenses and stamps for our area fishermen and women. We also have Launch Permits. Stop in and see us for yours today.
We can provide on-line registrations for All Terrain Vehicles (ATV’s), snowmobiles, and boats.*State and Service fees apply.

BUTLER : Siegel Title & Notary

Laura Dallas will gladly help you at our new Butler Office: Siegel Title & Notary. She is a seasoned Title Clerk and will get you in and out as quick as possible.

Laura’s hours are Monday – Friday 9am to 5 pm and Saturday 9 am to 1 pm.

Call and talk to Laura at 724-209-1575 or email her at