
10670 Route 322
Shippenville, PA 16254
Ph: (814) 226-9009
Fax: (814) 226-9064
Toll Free: (800) 617-8353
Butler
1109 N. Main Street Ext.
Butler, PA 16001
Ph: (724) 209-1575
Fax: (814) 240-5762
Toll Free: (800) 617-8353
Hours:
Monday – Friday: 8:30-5:00
Saturday – Sunday: Closed

Butler
1109 N. Main Street Ext.
Butler, PA 16001
Ph: (724) 209-1575
Fax: (814) 240-5762
laura@siegelinsurance.com
Hours:
Monday – Friday: 9:00-5:00
Saturday: 9:00-1:00
Sunday: Closed

Shippenville
10670 US Route 322
Shippenville, PA 16254
Ph: (814) 226-6412
Fax: (814) 226-6358
titlework@smathersagency.com
Hours:
Monday – Wednesday: 8:00-5:00
Thursday – Friday: 8:00-7:00
Saturday: 9:00-2:00
Sunday: Closed
All parties must be present at least one hour before closing for all title and notary work.
Insurance Solutions & Title Work Services
Auto & Leisure
Home & Property
Commercial
Health
Life & More
Title & Notary
Providing the best coverage & price the market has to offer.
Personal Insurance Solutions
Not all Polices are the Same
Personal insurance is often thought of like a commodity. At Siegel Insurance we want to change that perception. Since there are so many variables that comprise a personal auto or home policy, people tend to not fully understand what they are paying for or if they are covered properly.
The agents at Siegel Insurance want to make sure that you not only understand the coverage you carry on your policy, but we want to make certain you carry the appropriate coverage for your individual needs. Although proper coverage is the main concern for us as insurance agents, we fully understand that price is typically the main concern for our clients. That is why we represent a broad selection of respected insurance companies that give us the ability to shop the market and find you the best value available.
Auto / Vehicle Policies
There are many considerations when selecting the proper way to cover you and your family on an auto insurance policy. At Siegel Insurance, we will deliver all options in straightforward terms. We want to provide you with knowledge, protection, and savings.
-
Automobile Insurance
-
Classic/Antique Autos
-
Teen-Aged Drivers
-
Motorcycles
-
Boats
-
Snowmobiles
-
Jet Skis
-
ATV’s
Dedicated to Providing Superior Service

William P. Siegel
President
@Jamie Baker-Bills – Personal Lines
@Melissa Craig – Accounting Specialist
@Laura Dallas – Personal Lines – Butler Office
@Lindsey Fox – Personal Lines
@Matt Johnson – Personal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life
@Linda Lutz – Personal & Commercial Lines
@Deanna Miller – Personal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life
@Cindy Neely – Personal Lines
@Sheila Rathfon – Commercial Lines
@Amber Schreckengost – Personal Lines
@Jessica Shaffer – Personal & Commercial Lines, Health & Life
@Deb Shay – Commercial Lines
@Mary Lisa Siegel – Advertising & Marketing
@Shari Smith-Divido – Reception
@Tricia Stewart – Personal Lines
@Ryan Wisniewski – Personal & Commercial Lines – Butler office
We operate with an uncompromising belief in professionalism and integrity while striving to find innovative and effective ways to manage the needs of our clients.
Representing a Selection of A+ Rated Insurance Companies
